Lane Kiffin, the head football coach at Louisiana State University (LSU) has found himself at the center of controversy this fall, as the Tigers became the latest team to test the increasingly blurred line between college and professional sports.

Source: Instagram, @lsufootballnews
The controversy began after Dae’Quan Wright and Zxavian Harris left the University of Mississippi (Ole Miss) to declare for the NFL Draft. They both went undrafted before signing NFL contracts with the Cleveland Browns and New Orleans Saints respectively.
Neither appeared in a regular-season or pre-season game, but both spent time with the organizations over the summer. Both players were later cut before attempting to return to college football at LSU to reunite with their former coach.
“When I first saw this, I thought it was posted by a fake account,” said senior Benjamin Toy. “If you’re not good enough for the pros either play overseas or in another league that isn’t college.”
After going to court, a Louisiana judge granted a preliminary injunction clearing a path for Wright and Harris to receive another year of eligibility.
“The problem is that now with NIL and guys getting paid, there isn’t the same incentive to go pro as there was before,” said Mailroom Clerk Whitney Taylor.
Name, image and likeness (NIL) refers to a college athlete’s right to profit off of their fame, often through social media.
“If there isn’t a clear opportunity waiting for them, they’ll try and play for a 5th and 6th year if they can,” said Taylor.
The Southeastern Conference (SEC) stood in Wright and Harris’ way, arguing that their return violated a rule preventing athletes who signed professional contracts from competing in college. The disagreement eventually escalated into lawsuits between LSU and the SEC.
Ultimately, LSU left Wright and Harris off the roster for their season opener against Clemson and on Sept. 8 they filled their final two roster spots, closing the door on Wright and Harris playing college football in the 2026 season.
Although Wright and Harris will not play for LSU this season, their attempt to return has raised a larger question: At what point should a college athlete’s eligibility end?
“It’s way too complicated right now,” said sophomore Matt Berry. “I think athletes should be done after their 4 years unless there is an injury complication.”
The question becomes more complicated if an athlete gets injured or doesn’t have a clear path to play professionally.
“I wouldn’t be mad if you were allowed to declare for the draft and see if someone takes you before making the decision to return to school or not,” said senior Dave Alouidor. “Nothing is guaranteed for late-round picks, so you have to weigh out all your options.”
Situations like these add more questions to the ever-evolving landscape of college athletics. As athletes gain more freedom over where they play and how long they remain in college, determining when a college athlete can’t return may no longer be as simple as it once was.
“Loyalty in college football has been replaced by leverage,” said Taylor. “Everyone’s just shopping for the best deal.”
