Students and Faculty on Cornell Case

On Sept. 16 a woman going by the pseudonym Jane Doe filed a lawsuit against seven members of the Cornell University chapter of the Chi Phi Fraternity. The lawsuit was a result of the alleged incident that occurred back in Oct. 2024, where Jane Doe was reportedly sexually assaulted while incapacitated beyond the ability to consent at a Chi Phi party.

The re-opening of the case has sparked nation-wide conversation and disgust, including students at Sacred Heart.

“I was so confused how something so obviously out in the open could be kept so under the radar and not handled differently,” said senior Ryan Buchan, an orientation co-chair.

Senior Kylie Quercia, a nursing student, echoed similar thoughts.

“I believe individuals who come forward deserve to be taken seriously and supported, rather than dismissed or made to feel uncomfortable speaking out,” said Quercia.

Some, like Dr. Nidhi Shrivastava, an assistant teaching professor in the English department at Sacred Heart, are calling for changes within fraternal organizations.

“We need to rethink campus policies, especially those related to Greek life,” said Shrivastava. “We should introduce stronger regulations and trainings and zero-tolerance policies for chapters that tolerate dangerous behavior, hazing and sexual violence.”

Sacred Heart University’s Iota Tau chapter of the Delta Tau Delta (DTD) fraternity already implements these ideas.

“Delta Tau Delta has strict policies of no sorts of hazing or assault,” said brother Alex Arrubla. “We make our rules clear to new members, and if they are not followed, board members and our Director of Standards will be involved to determine suspension or dismissal.”

Philanthropic efforts of DTD also reinforce these policies.

“We work with The Center for Family Justice that helps out families or people that have suffered from sexual assault or domestic violence,” said brother Jorge Munguia. “We raise money with our ‘Walk a Mile in Her Shoes’ event, as well as our ‘Men Against Violence’ campaign where people who have experience sexual assault or domestic violence come to share their stories.”

Delta Tau Delta is not the only fraternity on campus that has taken steps to solve the issues of sexual violence. The Mu Lambda chapter of Sigma Chi enforces similar policies when it comes to these issues.

“We want everyone who is around the brothers to feel safe and to have a good time,” said philanthropy chair of Sigma Chi, Kevin Howard.

Regarding sexual assault trainings and education, Howard talked about how every new member goes through that process.

“We go over what to do, what not to do, what to do if you see or hear something and who to report it to,” said Howard. “We take all of that very seriously, but I do think there could always be more education across all Greek life.”

The reporting process can be challenging, and the Cornell 7 saw a lack of bystander intervention.

This was touched on during a colloquium centered around the book “#MeToo and Modernism,” co-written by Dr. Robin E. Field and Dr. Jerrica Jordan, who both spoke at the event on Oct. 15.

“The actions or inactions of bystanders, all those who are complicit in, or who prefer not to know about the abuse, or who blame the victims, often cause even deeper wounds,” said Field, quoting a book by Judith Lewis Herman.

Shrivastava moderated the discussion.

“I think if the Jane Doe rape victim-survivor had not filed charges two years later, we might never have known about the case,” said Shrivastava.

This gap between the time of the incident and when the case was re-opened, is due in part to how it was handled by the officials handling the case, including Cornell administration.

While certain Sacred Heart faculty cannot directly address Cornell’s response to the allegations, they have expressed their stance on Title IX procedures.

“We take allegations of sexual misconduct seriously and are committed to a fair and equitable process for all parties under our Title IX procedures,” said Title IX Coordinator Beth-Anne Voight Jause.

According to Shrivastava, gender dynamics can play a role in the reporting of these incidents.

“Gender-based and sexual violence are universal phenomena shaped by a rape culture that often excuses perpetrators’ behavior,” said Shrivastava.

Although official Title IX reports can be a long process, SHU students have emphasized society’s role in looking out for one another.

“I think a good chunk of that responsibility [preventing sexual assault] falls onto college students to support one another,” said Buchan.

“It is important for everyone to strive towards cultivating an environment where everyone can feel safe,” said Quercia.

For Shrivastava, the first building block to this new environment is discussion, keeping in mind SHU’s mission.

“Open discussion gives us an opportunity to come together as a community to prevent these incidents,” said Shrivastava. “We value the dignity of every human being.”

AP News contributed to this article.

About the author

Staff Writer

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *